Pumpkin Cookies with Brown Butter Icing

Yesterday afternoon, as I was trying to write a report, my mind kept wandering to pumpkin cookies.  Hard as a tried I couldn't get them off my mind.  I decided to take a break and search for a recipe... there are a ton of pumpkin cookies recipes on the web but I decided I would try Martha's Pumpkin Cookies with Brown Butter Icing. 

I must admit I had never dealt with brown butter before.  What a shame.... all these years and I have been missing out on this delicacy.  My new mission is to find a savory application for brown butter... I bet that would be fantastic. 

If you zoom in on the above picture, you can see little bits of brown in the frosting.  So delicious.  The frosting is a keeper for sure.  The cookies...well they were okay.  They were actually better than okay, they were good, but not great.  Perhaps my expectations were too high.  I'm afraid Martha let me down on this one.  I'll forgive her though since the frosting was so good.

The cookie recipe produced a cake like soft cookie texture. I was hoping they would be more like the Lofthouse cookies that unfortunately have me enamored.

Since the cookie batter is kind of thin (like cake batter), you can't just put scoops of batter on the cookie sheet- if you do, they will look like my first batch of cookies which were terribly ugly.  See below.

Martha's recipe calls for using a piping bag to pipe 1 1/2 inch rounds onto the cookie sheet.  I thought this seemed unnecessary and decided to just spoon the batter onto the sheets.  After my first batch looked so unpresentable, I decided to go the extra mile and do the piping technique. 
The picture below shows the cookies before being baked.  I forgot to take a pic of the cookies (sans icing) after they were baked.  Please forgive me....I'm still new to the blogging world.

I also forgot to take a picture of the brown butter.  I wish I would have because it truly was neat to see the color develop into a rich golden shade.  The smell was amazing as well.  This icing is nice because it hardens the perfect amount. 

Here is a link to the recipe.  I only made one change so I don't think I will take the time to re-write the recipe-  http://www.marthastewart.com/318741/pumpkin-cookies-with-brown-butter-icing.

Martha used 1 1/4 sticks butter in the icing.  I used 1 1/2 sticks in my icing. 

Side Note:  The cookie batter is delicious.  Mark and Natalie were fighting over who got to lick the mixing paddle.  Mark won but he graciously allowed Nat to have a few licks.  :)